American Gothic: Cast Rate: –☹️ Very Bad🙁 Bad😐 Average🙂 Good😃 Excellent🤩 Super! ★ Save Rating✔ Rating Saved! Notify me: –about new episodeabout new seasonabout end of season Subscribe✔ Subscription Saved! American Gothic Drama, Horror 9/22/95 – 2/6/98 United States GeneralEpisodesTranslationsCastCharactersGallery Cast See full cast → Gary Cole as Lucas Buck Lucas Black as Caleb Temple Paige Turco as Gail Emory Brenda Bakke as Selena Coombs Sarah Paulson as Merlyn Temple Nick Searcy as Ben Healy Jake Weber as Dr. Matt Crower