Do Over: Cast Rate: –☹️ Very Bad🙁 Bad😐 Average🙂 Good😃 Excellent🤩 Super! ★ Save Rating✔ Rating Saved! Notify me: –about new episodeabout new seasonabout end of season Subscribe✔ Subscription Saved! Do Over Comedy, Drama, Fantasy 9/19/02 United States GeneralEpisodesCastCharactersGallery Cast See full cast → Penn Badgley as Joel Larsen Angela Goethals as Cheryl Larsen Josh Wise as Pat Brody Natasha Melnick as Isabelle Meyers Michael Milhoan as Bill Larsen Gigi Rice as Karen Larsen Melinda Sward as Holly Kent Thomas F. Wilson as Coach Dorsey Julius Carry as Principal Glen Rudd Christopher Hatfield as Joel Jason Kravits as Dr. Nachman Judith Drake as Mrs. Hutchinson Jimm Giannini as Pizza Delivery Guy Kip Martin as Highschool Bully Davida Williams as Suzie